High Court Grants Permission for Judicial Review in Double Jeopardy Challenge
The family of Ryan Passey took an important step forward in their long-running pursuit of justice on 3 November 2026, when the High Court in Birmingham granted permission for their judicial review challenge to proceed to a substantive hearing.

Ryan was just 24 years old when he was fatally stabbed during an incident at Chicago’s nightclub in Stourbridge on 6 August 2017. Kobe Murray admitted stabbing Ryan but maintained that he had acted in self-defence. Following a trial at Birmingham Crown Court in February 2018, he was acquitted by the jury of both murder and manslaughter.
Ryan’s family have continued to pursue answers about the circumstances surrounding his death. Their concerns have included the evidence available at the original trial and information that emerged following further scrutiny of the case.
An independent review by West Yorkshire Police raised concerns about aspects of the evidence, following which West Midlands Police reopened its investigation. Further evidence subsequently came to light and senior prosecutors sought the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) to pursue a possible retrial under the double jeopardy rules. These allow an acquittal for a serious offence such as murder to be reconsidered in exceptional circumstances where there is new and compelling evidence.
Ryan’s family also previously pursued separate civil proceedings arising from his death, in which the civil court found that Ryan had been unlawfully killed.
The DPP ultimately declined to give consent for the double jeopardy process to proceed. The family are now challenging that decision and how it was reached through a judicial review.
The family are not asking the High Court itself to determine criminal guilt or innocence. Rather, the challenge concerns whether the DPP lawfully considered the relevant material, including the findings of the subsequent police review and the significance of the fresh evidence, when deciding not to take the case further.
High Court grants permission for judicial review
The family’s application for judicial review was initially refused on the papers. They then exercised their right to have the application reconsidered at an oral hearing before the High Court in Birmingham on 3 November.
Following submissions lasting more than an hour, HHJ Kolinsky granted permission for the judicial review to proceed, finding that there was an arguable case which warranted consideration at a substantive hearing.





Comments